Painter was quoted at one point saying the quickest way to get fired is to finish second on a bunch of recruits.Painter gets the most out of the talent he has. But very seldom is that talent top 10 or top 20 to begin with! Very seldom does painter sign a top 10 player. And he’s never sign two top 10 players in the same year! Admittedly you can’t recruit everybody. However, if you look at the recruitment of the top 10 prospects very rarely will you see that the player has even received an offer from Painter! You can only be as good as the players you recruit! I said the exact same thing about Purdue football. 4/5 star offensive linemen do exist! However if you do not recruit them, they will continue to go elsewhere!
I feel very confident in saying that the primary reason MP doesn’t land a bunch of five stars isn’t simply a failure to try, but he’s definitely going to prioritize the best guys where he thinks they have a realistic chance to close the deal.