I'd suggest there are many more than just the one contradiction, but that's a separate discussion.
I asked my question because, it would seem that, if one were to believe that there is an all-good god, and that everything that happens is part of that god's plan, then that person must also accept that the hurricane, and all the death and destruction it has caused, is a good thing, actually. There can be no evil in that world, as everything that happens must be good, including rape, murder, childhood cancer, etc. If it's NOT a good thing, then it must either not be part of the god's plan (which means that god is, apparently, useless, as it doesn't have the power to succeed at executing its own plan), or, if it IS part of the plan, then that god must not be all-good.
So, for Twin to suggest that the hurricane how his version of a god is showing us "who is really in charge," it would imply that Twin believes in an evil god, who does bad things to prove a point, or a stupid god who can't think of a better way to convey a message.
And yes, prayer is hella-confusing, and seems to be part of a contradictory worldview in which a god has a plan that's too mysterious for us to understand, but also that god might change the plan if you just ask nicely enough.
