Thanks for this review. We almost ordered from there last time we were at her parents' house.
Deep Dish
- Thread starter BSpecial
- Start date
I will give these all an open mind and not try to freak out anymore.. Burt’s did it more than anyone in here
And you respond multiple times to the same post now counting at three. You are an uneducated ass bitch I can tell and the best part is you may not be able to comprehend all the fancy words in these posts.
You’re a very ADD, sad blue-collar boy. The world needs more ditch-diggers.
Come on, isn’t it time to stop the pillow fight between you guys? I love pizza as much as anybody, but this thread just never seems to end……
lol I stopped a while ago.. my long post many many posts ago was written in a conciliatory tone. The mention of Burt’s got me riled up, but I acknowledged that I could have been more cooperative with the group. Dude is fighting with himself.
he has a belief too that makes me sick.. I don’t see actual ditch diggers doing an honest days work and look at them as less than. I look at them as doing an honest days work when they could be out there robbing someone
Nah this place is in NJ- he’s been doing the Jersey Shore recently
But yeah I pretty much go to places within 100 miles of Indy. I went to the original Bazbeaux in Broad Ripple last weekend. I’d been to the one on Mass Ave. a handful of times before, but never the BR location.
My local Pasquale’s- which I live half a mile from- has an 8.9 score on his One Bite App... but that is an average of just 2 reviews. A 7.8 and a 10.0.
Never had a calzone better than Bartolini’s. Went there once a week for it when I was working.
jersey was recently rated the #1 pizza state in the nation by some publication and although I haven’t been there yet, I’d doubt that that assessment is incorrect.
I’m a big believer that pizza in Illinois is good, but overrated
I think Connecticut has great quality pizza from what I see, but maybe according to this publication not the quantity of a New Jersey
I go to Philly in two weeks for the first time and it if I can swing an extra day out there I may keep going to new haven
Seems like Sally’s or Modern Apizza are the places to go there
Frank Pepe’s is the typical first choice. Sally’s and Modern are also good choices.
These were Portnoy’s scores:
Sally’s 9.2/10
Modern 8.8/10
Frank Peps 8.5/10
BAR 7.4/10
I’ve actually eaten all these pizzas myself and while Portnoy is something of a pizza connoisseur, I’ll trust my tastebuds and those of people who actually live around here to be the judge.
Frank Pepe’s, Original Sally’s, and Modern Apizza are all excellent. The people around here, myself included, generally prefer Frank Pepe’s over the other two. They are not the same. Their crusts and sauces have subtle, but tangible, differences. Again, they are all excellent and you can’t really go wrong with any of them. Frank Pepe’s was the first, and IMHO, the best of them.
Some of my favorites in Indiana:
Elkhart - Iechyd Da Brewing Company
Fairmount - Bad Dad Brewing Company
Nashville - Brozinni Pizzeria (another location was mentioned above) & Big Woods Pizza
It's too bad Mike's Italian Grill in Kokomo closed...
Bruno's (not part of the chain or Purdue's) in Plymouth was great but I think it got sold off and I haven't been that way to see if it's still any good.
Elkhart - Iechyd Da Brewing Company
Fairmount - Bad Dad Brewing Company
Nashville - Brozinni Pizzeria (another location was mentioned above) & Big Woods Pizza
It's too bad Mike's Italian Grill in Kokomo closed...
Bruno's (not part of the chain or Purdue's) in Plymouth was great but I think it got sold off and I haven't been that way to see if it's still any good.
Last edited:
Stumbled onto this thread starving so its been rough getting through it all. I live down in Louisiana and I am sure there is good pizza somewhere in the state, but I have not found it yet. Plenty of other good eats though.
Main Street down from the candy store
Brozinni Pizzeria Home • Brozinni Pizzeria - Nashville Indiana
Brozinni's, serving authentic New York Style Pizza. Serving Pizza by the Slice everyday at Lunch time. Come see us in beautiful Brown County, Indiana!
www.brozinnis.com
Oh nice. I know where that is. Didn’t realize it was Brozinni’sMain Street down from the candy store
Brozinni Pizzeria Home • Brozinni Pizzeria - Nashville Indiana
Brozinni's, serving authentic New York Style Pizza. Serving Pizza by the Slice everyday at Lunch time. Come see us in beautiful Brown County, Indiana!www.brozinnis.com
Hot damn. Gotta stop for one after the Sox game tomorrow now.
Why would we want to move on from such a productive thread?
Maybe we should turn this thread into a pizza review thread- or even make a new thread!
