I guess they were not deserving of consideration for the cfp . Or you could say they were just as deserving as IU was.
I believe it’s time to cut IU some slack and give them their props. They had a good year. Were they on the same level as PSU and OSU? No. But they were just as good or bad as several of the other teams in the cfp.
The CFP should never have been expanded to 12 teams and conferences like the mountain whatever, pac 12 and acc should never have been given automatic seeds. The overall seeding was terrible!
As for IU, I believe they could have beat Boise at, Arizona st and smu.
You don’t think Oregon and Georgia were deserving of the CFP?
The mountain west doesn’t get an automatic seed. It’s the top 5 conferences regardless, it’s been that way for the big six games for as long as I can remember. And when it was the P5 it was the top 6 conference champions.
Overall rankings was not Terrible. I think they got it right or at least close. Indiana was 8 and ahead of those 3 you mentioned… do you mean the fact they gave the conference champs byes? Yes that was questionable and no one is denying it. They made it clear with the status of conferences changing they would try it out this way and then evaluate it. You think two of the people on the large committee would get away with saying you other conferences don’t get byes? They needed it to play out so they can prove a point. I expect moving forward the brackets will be based on final rankings not conference champs. Then Texas and PSU would have gotten byes and indiana would have got to host Boise state.
Other changes I would like to see if they use quad wins like they do in basketball and just go with top 12 regardless of conference. Indiana still makes it but I suspect would have been passed up by Alabama (who would replace clemson) and SMU for the 10 seed and play tennessee in first round which I think would have been a good game.
Even in this scenario you would have had 5 conferences represented, but clemson wouldn’t have gotten in automatically and SMU would at least represent their conference.