It was obvious forward progress and he reached out late after the official was running in. Whistle is irrelevant according to the rule book.
Tennessee - Purdue Game Discussion Thread
- Thread starter KentuckyBoiler
- Start date
Too bad you all had to fake injuries to win
Mine was actually a sincere post.
Thanks for your obvious touch of class and sportsmanship on our board
Refs stand with a whistle in their mouth for a reason. The booth claimed the whistle was irrelevant but that’s not true. About a dozen penalties are decided upon the whistle and if they happen before or after that sound. Not the waving of hands.
What a dimwitted response. So you’re saying Tennessee should’ve known the refs would’ve called a forward progress when our rb was stopped for 1 second? Maybe kicking the FG was the better call. Doesn’t change the fact the refs took that game away from us. I’d never wish that against any opponent we play. Just a stupid way to end it.
Doesn't apply to forward progress. It's the ref's discretion.
wow, one of the gutsiest wins ever. down 21 to 7 they could have packed it in but they hung in there and won.
So, first it was the refs. Then fake injuries. Any other excuses? Go back to your hut, write a sad song for your banjo, or jug, or washboard….and mourn your loss.
Well, in spite of all the whining, it was an good game. Not at all what I expected after the start. If all things were equal, with our best still playing, it would have been ugly for the Vols.
Very happy with the way the 3rd, 4th, and so on, stepped up to the plate. Good things are coming.
Hoping this shot of Don Julio 1942 slows the heart rate a bit.
Very happy with the way the 3rd, 4th, and so on, stepped up to the plate. Good things are coming.
Hoping this shot of Don Julio 1942 slows the heart rate a bit.
On that last Tennessee play, is it legal for another offensive player to pull the ball carrier forward over the goal line?
And how about those goal line stands where the offense pushes a defensive player from the rear to make the ball carrier cross the goal line? I thought such"blocking" was illegal, but I never see it called.
Great to see the W!!!!!!!!
And how about those goal line stands where the offense pushes a defensive player from the rear to make the ball carrier cross the goal line? I thought such"blocking" was illegal, but I never see it called.
Great to see the W!!!!!!!!
It is not longer illegal to block a player forward, changed after the "Bush Push"
What a game by our Boilers! Boiler Up! I think I will remember this season for a while.
To all the complaining on the board from Tennessee fans. The injury stuff is crazy talk. We didn’t fake our starting DE injury on a 3rd and 9. We didn’t fake our starting MLB injury on 3rd and 2. And we certainly didn’t fake injuries when saving you a timeout. We had what looks like 3-4 defensive players battling hard through injuries.
The forward progress whistle I disagree with. I wish it had not come down to that. Realistically though you guys blew your chance to win imo at the end of regulation with some horrible play calling.
i am honestly shocked we were even in this game given the injuries and opt outs. Hats off to most of the Tennessee fans who have visited the last several weeks. Most of you have been good sports and good luck going forward.
Boiler Up!
To all the complaining on the board from Tennessee fans. The injury stuff is crazy talk. We didn’t fake our starting DE injury on a 3rd and 9. We didn’t fake our starting MLB injury on 3rd and 2. And we certainly didn’t fake injuries when saving you a timeout. We had what looks like 3-4 defensive players battling hard through injuries.
The forward progress whistle I disagree with. I wish it had not come down to that. Realistically though you guys blew your chance to win imo at the end of regulation with some horrible play calling.
i am honestly shocked we were even in this game given the injuries and opt outs. Hats off to most of the Tennessee fans who have visited the last several weeks. Most of you have been good sports and good luck going forward.
Boiler Up!
I'm saying your coach gambled on 4th down twice instead of taking points, dumb@ss! There are a lot of variables that can go against you in a one and done situation and every time you do it you tempt fate. Every time you do it increases the overall probability that it will fail for whatever reason... Should have just taken the points is all I was saying. Your coach shot himself in the foot. However as far as the call was concerned, watching in real time, I thought his forward progress was stopped b4 he reached out (I also thought his knee was down). Upon replay and further review, I became concerned about both of those. Obviously his knee was, in fact, not down, but according to rules, if the ref called the play dead for forward progress before he reached, it was dead when he determined (even if the actual whistle blow was not heard until after). Them's the rules, live with them...
Lol. We had 23 players transfer if I remember correctly. Like I said earlier,it was a good game. Just a shame it had to end with a bs call.
Like I said in my post... if those were the rules, yalls fullback doesn’t run for near as many yards. There were multiple plays where he wasn’t moving for at least as long as our running back on that final play. The refs are inconsistent, and it showed there.
yeah, the rule is it is up to the ref... inconsistent refs suck, I agree... sucks to be you (in this case). It's sucked to be Purdue many many times, so we feel ya...
My understanding of the rule is that you can now push the runner without it being a penalty for illegally assisting the runner. NFL did that in 2005 and NCAA in 2013, IIRC. However, pulling or lifting I thought was still a penalty.
Heck of a battle for both teams - one of those games where you could make a case for either team winning or losing......really thought Tennessee was going to win it in regulation with a FG with three time-outs left.....maybe should have tried a couple more runs, but hindsight is 20/20.
I like Purdue's trajectory right now.....we shall see.
But he wasn't parallel to the ground laying on top of another player.
To the Purdue fans on this board,
Thanks for another great game discussion season. It was fun.
2022 looks to be very bright for our team, if we can get healthy and continue to improve on some glaring weaknesses in certain areas in the offseason. Here is to wishing you a Happy and Prosperous Year in 2022!
Thanks for another great game discussion season. It was fun.
2022 looks to be very bright for our team, if we can get healthy and continue to improve on some glaring weaknesses in certain areas in the offseason. Here is to wishing you a Happy and Prosperous Year in 2022!
Both teams suffered from injuries late. Quit crying. You make your whole fan base look bad with that nonsense
I did not expect is to win or even keep it close to be honest. I think Tennessee was a little over hyped and we maybe were a little better beyond Bell and Karlaftis than people previously thought.
I’m not so sure that the Tennessee players allowed to grab their running backs jersey and pull him into the end zone. Isn’t that a penalty? Yeah, it is… The player with the ball is not allowed to be pulled forward by a teammate in an attempt to advance the ball…
