the key factor to look at is what led to the losses. There have been a lot of great QBs with a cannon for an arm that throw into a crowd, or cannot read defenses, or make critical errors at the wrong time in games. there at lot of QBs that are great from the 20 to the 20, but can't score. there was a QB at texas tech about 10-20 years ago who had a tremendous arm, but was not accurate He was a first round pick based on his talent and potential. And then there were guys like Brady and Montana. great QBs with average arms. Sometimes, you can correct mistakes, but sometimes you can't. As a Packers fan, I loved Jay Cutler as much as Favre. Jay was 0-11 or something like that against green bay. Jay was a great QB, just not against green bay.
As players go, our local high school has a 4* TE who has received a multitude of power 5 offers, and our team is a mediocre 2/3 level team. he accepted an offer to Arkansas.