This is why i feel holt may be a little overrated. He did a nice job his first year but not so great this year. Gonna need to step it up next season.
I can’t tell if this is TIC or not, but I’ll bite.
The defense 247 ratings and best offer outside of Purdue
2014 class:
Keiwan Jones - 2 star 2048 - Iowa State
Antonio Blackmon unranked with no rating
JT - unranked with no rating
2015 class:
Marcus Bailey - .84 991 overall - BC/Duke
2016 class:
Watts - .80 1928 overall - Cal
Neal - .81 1858 overall - Boisie State/Oregon State
Smiley -.81 1658 overall - Troy
BT - unranked with no rating
2017 class
Reviere - .81 1851 overall - WKU
Higgins - .80 JUCO 280 - New Mexico State
Jones - .79 2 Star 2280 - Uconn
Barnes - .77 2 Star 2697 - Toledo
Major - .76 2 Star 3082 - WKU
You telling me he is overrated with that taking the field? Four 2 stars (3 only have 1 year experience), 3 unrated/unranked. One player in the top 1000.
Holt has been nothing short of a genius. His first year in he had way more talent on the defensive side of the ball and he had a pass rush.
For some perspective...
2019 class
GK - .96 79 - Everybody
Grant - .92 258 - Notre Dame, Michigan, BC
Faucheux - .89 327 - Penn State, Alabama, BC
Hunter - .87 603 - UK, Cincy
Saunders - .86 775 - Iowa State (but didn’t really blow up until after he committed to Purdue).
Graham - .86 794 - BC, Minnesota
Allen - .85 975 - Virginia
Beverly -.85 1076 - BC, Cincy
Triplett -.80 2221 ( lowest rated in the entire ‘19 class and still higher than 6 starters (if you include BT who is starting as JT is injured)) and same as 2 others.
Help is coming and in a big way. Not sure that we see more than 3 as big time time contributors from the ‘19 class (next year), just due to the adjustment of the game/size/competition. But I expect that top 3 to step in immediately because they are the most ready physically.
I don’t have the time or inclination to map out the ratings of the other Big teams, but I imagine Purdue would be at the bottom when you account for the rating/experience of their players. They held there own against OSU that trounced Michigan (considered to have one of the best defenses and loaded with talent). And this was all with next to zero pass rush. If you want to judge Holt, judge him in 2-3 years when the ‘18 and ‘19 classes come into their own. He was competing in the Big with, at best, average mid-major talent. He was able to overachieve and get the players to buy in.