So I don’t agree at all, but I understand your rationale if Carsen leaves, but if Carsen stays I don’t get the 9-12 seed logic at all. Purdue will have a great group of guards with Carsen, Eastern, Hunter, Sasha, Newman, and Thompson covering the 1-3 positions. With Williams and Haarms, Purdue will have a great post rotation. That leaves the 4 where I expect great things from Wheeler. I know that replacing Eifert sounds close to impossible, but Coach Painter is a smart guy and will figure it out.You brought up IU, not me.
Wheeler has shown flashes, but nothing consistent. Newman is still in high school. Hard to depend on a not top 50 recruit to be instant impact. Everything we have seen/heard is that Haarms, EB, Williams, and Dow are 5s. That leaves Wheeler to fill out the 4 spot unless we get grad transfer.
We are thin everywhere but the 5 spot.