Purdue vs Arizona Gameday Thread 12/27/17

[purduepat1969]

What am I missing? It's not where the ball crosses the out of bounds marker. It's where he lands because he wasn't out of bounds until he landed...

 

[phila]

Purdue Jonah Hill giving the refs the what for!

 

[BoilerBulldog]

So they said the spot is where the ball crosses the out of bounds line not where it finishes? Guess I never realized that...

Why wouldn’t it be?

 

[TopSecretBoiler]

So they said the spot is where the ball crosses the out of bounds line not where it finishes? Guess I never realized that...

I don't think that's the full rule...

 

[BoilerGal74]

Tate smells blood in water....D better step it up

 

[IndySouthsider]

Ha they pushed Robinson down from behind and laid on him

 

[TopSecretBoiler]

Why wouldn’t it be?

because you're not out until you land out. It's not a plain to cross. I think they f'd that up in the booth.

 

[KentuckyBoiler]

Come on offense. Give the defense some help!

 

[purduepat1969]

Does Anthrop ever try to return a punt? It's like an automatic fair catch every time....

 

[70boiler]

I know what I heard the "expert official" just say...

 

[gelesen]

so if your streaking down the sidelines in bounds but stick the ball out over the line it out of bounds? I think not. So why is it on this type play.

 

[PaBoiler78]

Tate smells blood in water....D better step it up

we squandered great field position too much.

 

[boilerpete1]

So for example could you be standing inbounds and reach out and catch a pass that was over the OB line and pull it back in

 

[PurdueForCorndogs]

because you're not out until you land out. It's not a plain to cross. I think they f'd that up in the booth.

It's correct call, just like a punt or kickoff, when it cross out of bounds line that's where it is marked. It is an invisible wall of sorts to infinity.

Also if we don't win I'm banning Foster Farms products with my Home Owner's Association for the neighborhood.

 

[purduepat1969]

so if your streaking down the sidelines in bounds but stick the ball out over the line it out of bounds? I think not. So why is it on this type play.

This is exactly what I was thinking. He wasn't out of bounds until he landed. That was a terrible review call.

 

[70boiler]

You mean if I am running down the sideline with the ball in my arm over the out of bounds and my feet in the ball goes there?

 

[BoilerBiker]

so if your streaking down the sidelines in bounds but stick the ball out over the line it out of bounds? I think not. So why is it on this type play.

exactly
I would like to understand their ruling too

 

[arcb102000]

So you are telling me that a runner or receiver running down the sideline and stays totally inbounds but his arm carrying the ball goes over the line that play is halted?

I have never seen that call made and I do not believe it.

 

[IndySouthsider]

Dammit. Is Pagano wearing a Brohm mask on the sideline

 

[PurdueForCorndogs]

You mean if I am running down the sideline with the ball in my arm over the out of bounds and my feet in the ball goes there?

For example, think a diving tip toe sideline catch at the goal line. If I catch it inbounds and the ball doesn't go inside of the pylon ever it is marked where the ball left the field if I never brought it back in. Even though my body may have fallen across the goaline if the ball was outside the pylon (sideline side) it is not a TD.

 

[KentuckyBoiler]

Our OL is just not giving Sindelar any time

 

[PaBoiler78]

So you are telling me that a runner or receiver running down the sideline and stays totally inbounds but his arm carrying the ball goes over the line that play is halted?

I have never seen that call made and I do not believe it.

don't we have any screen plays?

 

[TopSecretBoiler]

It's correct call, just like a punt or kickoff, when it cross out of bounds line that's where it is marked. It is an invisible wall of sorts to infinity.

Also if we don't win I'm banning Foster Farms products with my Home Owner's Association for the neighborhood.

show me the rule.

 

[phila]

This whole half has been intentional grounding.

 

[ahhculdee]

You have to be smarter than that.

 

[pu1985]

The O took some serious sleeping pills at halftime...

 

[IndySouthsider]

So if the ball is out of bounds but my arms catch the ball and both feet are in bounds. Is it a catch?

 

[PurdueForCorndogs]

So you are telling me that a runner or receiver running down the sideline and stays totally inbounds but his arm carrying the ball goes over the line that play is halted?

I have never seen that call made and I do not believe it.

The play would never be stopped as you were not down or touched out of bounds. This only comes into play if the runner is down, wherever the ball broke the out of bounds line is it marked, if it was not brought back into the field of play before the runner down.

Also I've only reffed at the YMCA hahaha, but I've played and watched alot of football growing up. #CouldBeWrong #BarSForTheWin #HoosiersSuck

 

[TopSecretBoiler]

For example, think a diving tip toe sideline catch at the goal line. If I catch it inbounds and the ball doesn't go inside of the pylon ever it is marked where the ball left the field if I never brought it back in. Even though my body may have fallen across the goaline if the ball was outside the pylon (sideline side) it is not a TD.

not if you had a foot down lol...good try. he was established in bounds and fell out of bounds. Your comparison is terrible.

 

[KentuckyBoiler]

Can Brohm throw a chair out on the sidelines to get these guys fired up?

 

[arcb102000]

What happens if a receiver catches the ball ove r the sidline but his feet are inbounds? It is no catch? Really? That is bs.

 

[phila]

I love the sight of raw chicken breasts falling through the air.

 

[Lionheart1]

Apparently 1st half was too easy and guys thought it was over.

 

[BoilerBiker]

So if the ball is out of bounds but my arms catch the ball and both feet are in bounds. Is it a catch?

today that would not be ruled a catch

 

[Boilerhaymaker]

21 is Bailey, so what are you on about?

This really require clarification? Bailey has been solid. Anthony...meh

 

[TopSecretBoiler]

today that would not be ruled a catch

i mean we need new rules on the spot. clearly makes the game better.

 

[BoilermakerD]

Ohio state and Michigan aren’t out until they land... neither is Notre Dame

 

[boilermaker75]

For example, think a diving tip toe sideline catch at the goal line. If I catch it inbounds and the ball doesn't go inside of the pylon ever it is marked where the ball left the field if I never brought it back in. Even though my body may have fallen across the goaline if the ball was outside the pylon (sideline side) it is not a TD.

Nope, that is a TD. I have seen that happen many, many times.

 

[Purdue Grad in Texas]

C'mon Boilers......a nice drive would be.......nice.

 

[IndySouthsider]

Arizona is hell a fast.