I'm a proponent of not giving out offers to 2 star athletes early. Because they fill up your class, and leave you with flexibility problems later. you either end up keeping the 2 star athletes, or you look like a n ogre telling them, sorry, we have to let you go because we found somebody better. To me, the 2 star athlete is the one you should sign at the later signing period. and if he signs elsewhere, there will always be another 2 star athlete or a juco or a transfer that will become available to fill that scholarship.
Should we keep a scholarship open for Stepp? I would say yes. However, according to Stepp, Purdue has informed him if he doesn't sign early, they are going to give his scholarship to somebody else.
I see Stepp as a similar situation to Tyger. Tyger wants to look around before making a decision. Painter has 2 scholarships left for the later signing period. Is he holding one for Tyger? or is he holding them just to see if somebody else may transfer or blossom? Tyger has to know by waiting, he risks other choices being already filled. Stepp has to realize this as well.
One issue most athletes don't realize is that the majority of scouting is done at summer camps and during your fall season. There are not going to be that many more additional offers coming . We have a 4* TE in our community named Ford. he has offers from all of the top 10 schools. he's decided to wait until the Army all star game before making a decision. The reality is, he's not going to receive any more or any better offers than he already has. and by waiting, he could lose some of his offers. He's leaning to Georgia, with offers from ALA, Auburn, Mich , OSU, and many others. by waiting, he could lose out.
I believe Purdue should keep at least one scholarship available. I also believe Purdue should stop recruiting 2 star athletes, because I believe we can do better. And if you don't like the use of star ratings, look at the offers an athlete receives. I also believe we should be going after the same athletes teams like UW, Louisville, Rutgers, Maryland, WV , IU, Iowa, Pitt, UK, Tenn, Ark, Vandy, and Minn are targeting. the days of targeting the same players as Marshall, MAC teams, military , and other FBS teams should be behind us. We should be targeting players that other power 5 teams are recruiting. and Brohm is starting to do so.