My son played low level D1 basketball (MAC level) and the town played a huge part in his decision. Yes, the coach's attitude toward him mattered, but the town was an important aspect (as in Wright State, he hated Dayton). Yes, the top level players may not have time to care, but they don't realize that when they are being recruited. They are not consumed with weights or classes in HS.
Sure, the blue bloods make the town not matter. It's the lower levels of recruit that it affects more. So, this post may not relate to the conversation, but at some level, it does make a difference. But at times the recruit doesn't realize the differences before they get on campus. Assumptions still exist.
PLUS, having spent a lot of time with the incoming football recruits over the years, it is interesting that a couple of the things that upset the guys the most are the facts that there is no Church's Chicken, that Yellow Rice is not available in the stores, and that the girls on campus don't worship the ground that the football players walk on. WL is not the south and they recognize it. Now, we can debate forever these comments, but if you interview the players,. these comments will come up.