Let's look at the whole picture here. Temple was a doormat in the Big East for 14 years. The Big East then expelled Temple for low attendance.
Al Golden became HC when they were independent and built them into a winner in a much weaker MAC conference. Golden left and Temple bottomed out again. Golden was replaced with Steve Addazio who was canned after two years.
Then Temple joins a much stronger AAC and hires Matt Rhule. Rhule took Temple from last place to first place in three years and they're tied for the conference lead again this year.
Big East (1991–2004)
1991 Jerry Berndt 2–9–0 0–5–0 8th
1992 Jerry Berndt 1–10–0 0–6–0 8th
1993 Ron Dickerson 1–10–0 0–7–0 8th
1994 Ron Dickerson 2–9–0 0–7–0 8th
1995 Ron Dickerson 1–10–0 1–6–0 7th
1996 Ron Dickerson 1–10 0–7 8th
1997 Ron Dickerson 3–8 3–4 T-5th
1998 Bobby Wallace 2–9 2–5 T-6th
1999 Bobby Wallace 2–9 2–5 T-5th
2000 Bobby Wallace
4–7 1–6 7th
2001 Bobby Wallace
4–7 2–5 6th
2002 Bobby Wallace
4–8 2–5 T-6th
2003 Bobby Wallace
1–11 0–7 7th
2004 Bobby Wallace
2–9 1–5 T-6th
Independent (2005–2006)
2005 Bobby Wallace
0–11
2006 Al Golden 1–11
Mid-American Conference (2007–2011)
2007 Al Golden
4–8 3–3 T-4th (East)
2008 Al Golden
5–7 4–4 T-2nd (East)
2009 Al Golden
9–4 7–1 T-1st (East)
L 30–21 EagleBank Bowl
2010 Al Golden
8–5 5–3 3rd (East)
2011 Steve Addazio 9–4 7–1 2nd (East)
W 37–15 New Mexico Bowl
Big East (2012)
2012 Steve Addazio
4–7 2–5 7th
American Athletic Conference (2013–present)
2013 Matt Rhule 2–10 1–7 T-9th
2014 Matt Rhule
6–6 4–4 6th
2015 Matt Rhule
10–4 7–1 1st (East)
L 17–32 Boca Raton Bowl
2016 Matt Rhule 6
–3 4
-1 1st (East)
Total: 448–580–52
National championship Conference title Conference division title