I was just a grade school kid and almost never posted when I first started reading the Purdue basketball forum on Indy Star (around 1995-1996).
I remember there was an IU fan that went by "Bob H." I also recall some IU fan (it might have been that guy that posted as Don Romeo) making up a recruit and really talking him up. They said that the recruit's name was Matt Gage and that he was an athletic 6'9 power forward from Alaska. They were acting like this guy was the next college superstar and that IU was gonna get him, haha. Nowadays, with so many more websites (specifically recruiting sites like this one) to verify these things, no one would ever believe something like that. I think he had some people buying into "Matt Gage" for a little while, though.