That Ole Miss loss is ABSOLUTELY what people make it out to be...it exposed IU for the genuine fraud that it was...the Ole Miss JV team rolled out and beat IU in a game that it deemed was beneath them to even play in.
Yes, playing in front of fans has been/will be problematic for IU...in part, because they are not accustomed to it (see last Saturday for further evidence).
Penix was incredibly overrated...and he is showing it...he is talented, but, makes bad decisions and bad reads as well...it was there last year, but, ignored...now, absent the mobility, it is all that more on display.
8-4 only seemed reasonable because you were looking at last year...which was a fluke...COVID had a tremendous impact...in multiple ways. IU was not winning 8 games this year unless, like last year, everyone that they played (outside of OSU) continued to suck...which was not likely. Last year was the literal perfect storm of circumstances for IU...they capitalized in general to their credit (albeit laying an egg when it mattered most in the bowl game against Ole Miss' JV team)...back to reality this year, just as many had said would be the case.
I don't care how allegedly well IU's defense played...if ST and offense sucks, the end result is a loss, and, that is ultimately all that matters. As a Bears fan...I know that all too well...as a Purdue fan, I have seen the opposite/reverse proven time and time again (offense good enough to win/defense and ST not). You may (or may not be right), but, it is a moot point...as they lost twice...for whatever reason(s).