I’m not defending the current situation because something is obviously not working, but this hasn’t been just a Hazell/Griggs problem at PU. PU has had a recurring issue with kicker consistency. Since 1998, Dorsch & Wiggs are the only kickers to have multiple seasons making more than 60% of their kicks.The others all have had more seasons below 60% than above it. Just for reference, making 60% of FGs is nothing to write home about as 60% ranks #104 of 111 of qualifying kickers this season (per ESPN).
-Dorsch’s FG%’s: 72.7, 58.1, 70.6, 81.5
-Wiggs’ FG%’s: 72.7%, 66.7, 78.9, 76
The others:
-Lacevic’s connected on only 52.6% of FGs in his only season.
-Ben Jones hit 83.3% in 2003. The follow 2 years, his FG%’s were 55.6% and 57.1%.
-Chris summers hit 81.8% in 2007. The season before he hit only 40% and the season after only 50%
-Griggs was able to convert 80% of FGs as a Jr. In his other seasons, he’s hit 57.1%, 50%, and is currently at 33.3%.
None of those kickers in the “others” group showed any sort of trend of improvement & none had his best season as his last season. I have no idea if that is normal (kickers are notoriously fickle?), but it seems really bizarre to me.