Is there talent at the QB position? Definitely, but talent doesn't always equate to production on the field. That really doesn't always translate to production on the field when the offensive line in Hazel's first year was abysmal and last year players still seemed to be pushing against the grain at times. In all honesty, and I know many on here are tired of hearing about Danny Hope, but his coaching and lack of ability to sustain a program in the long term with clear vision and goals really hurt in the short term of Coach Hazel's tenure here.
I have been to a spring practice already and I will say this:
Etling: Has talent but seems so wrapped up in not making mistakes that he rarely takes any chances down the field. I don't care how talented you are, if you aren't willing to throw the ball in to tight windows and allow your playmakers to make plays down the field, you aren't going to be successful. He also lacks true gusto and raw leadership qualities. Sure, working hard and being the first in and last out sets you up to be a leader...but if you don't command respect and demand your peers work up to your level, you won't lead men that are 18-24. Michael Jordan, beyond being the most intense to ever play basketball DEMANDED those around him play at his level. Scottie Pippen wouldn't have been Scottie Pippen without Michael Jordan DEMANDING that he be like him in ever facet.
Appleby: Seems to truly have the command of his peers around him but seems to be hurt by just a lack of true top flight ability. Sub-par arm strength and at times wild attempts to make a play seem to even out his above average command and respect. Most of those on the team that give him that respect seem to do so not only because he works hard but that he demands that respect being the QB of a power 5 school.
Blough and Sindelar: It is hard to make a determination of these two as I have only seen them once a piece but Blough seems to be the most athletic of the 4 QB's but also the least likely to wow you physically. Very short and with an arm I would liken to that of Etling's, he makes mistakes (as most young QB's do) that this team can't really afford to have at times next season. Sindelar is all the qualities of the three previous in one package and as Stacy said in the chat yesterday (and I mentioned in my practice summary from Thursday), had Sindelar not blown his knee out he might have walked away with the job this spring because he seems to just be that much better at this point than the others. He has a top flight arm, height, and can push the ball down the field with ease. As Stacy already said, if he can get healthy enough by the start of summer workouts and camp, he could conceivably make a push to start this year. Unless he comes out guns blazing I doubt he takes the job from Appleby but he could if Appleby struggles or gets hurt.