It is not clear to me the writer didn't think much of Purdue's offense. It appeared more to me that he thought the execution of the offense was the issue, rather than the offense. If someone read something different, please help me understand.
I did pick up this "It’s also much harder for a big man to affect the game at the NCAA level, because so much of their success depends on the quality of their teammates.
Not many college teams run a good offense or space the floor properly, and even fewer have competent point guard play. Without a floor general who can control tempo, enter the ball into the post, or consistently hit the roll man, life is difficult for a pivot, no matter how talented. Conversely, a big man who plays on a well-coached team with proper spacing and facilitation can post statistics that overstate his talent level.
Any player that depends on others to get him the ball faces to a degree all of the above items. A coach attempts to place the best team out on the floor to win as much as possible. The execution of that approach has a lot to do with the combination of the skill and athleticism of the players willing to go to the school, able to make it at that school, along with the coach thinking he can be successful. During Matt's time (same offense, just different tweets to take advantage of the skills) we have seen teams run up and down the floor, played small ball and were dominant in the low post in a half court set. There has been much full court offense, some full court offense and rarely any full court offense all a function of the cards he had. There is not a coach alive that doesn't wish for great spacing, but if the players don't have the threat to stretch the D, why would the defense allow that team spacing unless they thought more pressure was even more effective than not guarding them?
Did Matt's discipline towards AJ make him a better player or hurt the perception? I believe the bottom line was a better player, but a reasonable debate could commence. Does any of it matter? AJ will get drafted. He has the ability to negotiate a better future than whatever he starts out with if he performs. As always, it is about AJ and not being a victim like much of the country in something...