Not a fan of recruiting middle schoolers. Look at the basketball side. That has definitely come back to bit multiple programs in the ass a lot of times.
A lot of things can change. The kid has a lot of developing to do. He could get hurt, then UGA would most likely rescind the offer and look bad for it.
As far as Kirby Smart, I don't think he fixes UGA's problem. The problem is....he's not Nick Saban, he's only worked for him. I think a lot of things are changing internally in the program....but Richt was already an A+ recruiter. Richt was already a decent offensive mind. And nothing changes as far as the fact that Nick Saban still coaches Alabama.
I think Richt was the perfect fit for UGA back when he was hired and became a victim of the expectations he set within the fan base. I think a lot of fans brush over 2012 where we were 2 yards and 1 fluke play away from beating Alabama, winning the SEC and likely cruising through the national title game, beating ND like a redheaded step child.
I think the fan base was ready for a change and that's fine....but I honestly don't see Kirby Smart being our coach in 5 years. I just see more of the same as it was with Richt. Florida is on the up. Tennessee is on the up. Only 1 team from the east can go to the SECCG...where you likely have to face guess who....Nick Saban....